I would prefer to find a 2010 with low miles for high $60s that has a clean title. If you are short on cash to buy a clean title 2011 and have to have a 2011, then go for the lemon. However, the value will always be lower on a lemon car when you go to sell it as well and it will be harder to move, since most people avoid these cars.
Good luck on your search
Good luck on your search